The Citadel Of Self.


    
When arguments for or against the existence of a God are put forward, some dismiss them as irrelevant. What matters, they say, "Is not proof or disproof but the daily experience of living with God". This they say, "Is the reality and beside it all arguments are irrelevant and the truth really resides in the experience of the individual". This is the retreat of religion into the "Citadel of Self". One of the obvious features of the past few centuries has been the shrinking of the area, subject to a religious explanation. At one time, a religious view of the physical world was universally accepted. When that position was lost; religion took refuge in the view that the human species was a special creation of a god, and consequently, involved a special relationship. Now that has been shown to be nonsense. Religion immures itself, in what is said to exist deep in the nature of the individual.
 
Buddhism
    This is a view difficult to refute, since it removes the controversy beyond normal human knowledge and reasoning. In this connection, it is of interest to consider, a commentary from another religion say, Buddhism, which has no belief in a God, as "Nyanaponika Thera" puts it.
    "But for the earnest believer, the God idea is more than a device for explaining external facts like the origin of the World etc. It is for him, or supposed to be, an inner experience that can bestow a strong feeling of certainty, not only as to God’s existence somewhere out there, but as to God’s consoling presence and closeness to the devotee. However, this feeling of certainty requires a close scrutiny. Such scrutiny will reveal that in most cases, the God experience is only the devotee’s projection of his ideal (a more or less noble one) and of his fervent wish, and a deeply felt need to believe. To these projections is given a strong emotional emphasis and they receive life through man’s powerful capacity of imagination, in the sense of image forming, visualization, myth creation, etc. These projections are largely conditioned by the influences of childhood impressions, education, tradition, social environment, etc; and are identified with the images and concepts of whatever religion the devotee follows. In the case of very many of the most sincere believers, a searching self-analysis would show that their God experience, have no more specific content than this".
    Those who claim experience of God would reject the above rational explanation. More to the point perhaps would be to ask them, "How they know that their sort of comfort or joy (or whatever emotions are aroused in them) is God"? They cannot know this; as intensity of conviction is not knowledge.
    Nor can the proponent of personal experience, explain that experience. That it seems real is not necessarily significant. The experience of a mental patient, who thinks he is Napoleon, seems (to him) equally real.
    If the source of experience is inexplicable, then no name should be given to it, and no dogmatic assertions made about it. To go further and make the simplistic allegation that the experience is in fact of a God, merely indicates an attempt at a naively egotistic self-justification.
 
"Masters of The Citadel Of Self" is Hollywood, as one of my Children has just pointed out to me! "The Pirates Of The Caribbean" in ‘Davy Jone’s Locker’. Davy Jone’s wonderful playing of the Organ, with his long, long, tentacles! How about having faith in Hollywood, History, Evolution, Science, and Cosmology: surely, enough for anyone to get by on!

About luckyme0

My First family, second marriage, bringing up my 18-year-old twins, boy, and girl. I am a third generation Humanist, who has some old handwritten information and notes; collected over many years. Someone may find the articles interesting, or helpful. They could bring back a little ‘reality’, after being ‘shocked’ and ‘brainwashed’, by some malicious group, or institution (REBT Therapy). People should know better, than to do this, to our very young, and the ‘obviously’ vulnerable! Go to easily accessible, non-superstitious knowledge that is not charlatanism! https://charleslizzy.com/2011/08/06/independent-schools-inspectorate-isi-marketing-spirituality-buzzword-or-maybe-even-for-you-to-shiver-at-the-something/ The blog has given me an incentive to order my thoughts, learn, and read up again, after a few non-thinking years of (very silly) imagination and passion. Why not, get your own key to a ‘door’, customise it to suit you, and it can be, all of your very own! Don’t believe, or be led by someone else’s; inherited, stupid, and a very likely (past, and not of today’s) ‘totally preposterous reality’s’. Only some interest in the ‘really big questions’, keeps life above the level of a farce, and very little else! KEEP THINKING! Some of the posts may need some correcting. Interests: REBT Counselling, Atheism, Secularism, Humanism, Psychology, Reading, Popular Science, School Ethos, Philosophy, History, Family, Parenting, Psychology, Horse Riding, Sailing, Rescue Boat Driver, Skiing (Teppichswinger), TV Documentaries, Motorbike Cross Country Riding, Volunteer Sports Stewarding, Writing, Primitive Man, Pre-history, Social Anthropology, British Humanist Association, BHA, Meaning of Life, The Big Questions, Where am I, What am I, Why am I, Hippie Love, Knowledge, Education, Globalisation. Favorite quote: “The world belongs to those who, at least to some degree, have figured it out.” Carl Sagan, ‘The Demon Haunted World’, ‘Contact’, and other famous books DVD ‘Cosmos’. The warning of another and horrendous, “Age of Superstition”. “Isn’t there something deeply absurd in the presumption that children ought to inherit beliefs from their parents. It can be deeply damaging, even lethally divisive. A ‘them’, with an ‘against us’, mentality” – Professor Richard Dawkins. “The will to believe is stronger than mere reason in the vast majority of people” – Dr J.Brown, Army Psychologist of the 1960′s. Humans will believe in almost anything, in fact, they seek it! Why? “98% of us, trained to be just good consumers, let’s train our children to be the 2% who have their very own creativity and discernment”; quote by a famous surreal artist. “The lack of reason brings forth monsters”. “Global interconnectedness is lethal against mass religion, nationalism, racism, and other destructive memeplexes. Let us connect everybody they hate it in restrictive regimes”; from the ‘meme learning group’, Richard Brodie’s book, ‘Virus Of The Mind’ (Richard Brodie a designer for ‘Microsoft Word’). Following on, J.Bronowski, and ‘The Ascent Of Man’ TV series, and a book http://www.bbcshop.com/science+nature/the-ascent-of-man/invt/9781849901154/ with the last DVD in this series, ‘The Long Childhood’ being especially revealing. ‘Prehistory’ and the ‘Making of the Human Mind’ by Colin Renfrew, with P.Wilson’s, ‘The Domestication of the Human Species’, and Nigel Spivey’s, TV series and book, ‘How Art Made The World’, offers some further explanations. Latest reading: Jared Diamond http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jared_Diamond
This entry was posted in Religion. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.